Cedarburg, WI phone 262-376-0601
  • Menu
  • Locally Sourced
  • History
  • Employment
  • Contact Us
  • Cedarburg, WI
    phone262-376-0601

Hefner's Menu

Off The Grill Sides Kids Meals Drinks Custard Specials >

 

Off The Grill Sides Kids Meals Drinks Custard Specials

Off The Grill

Jumbo Hamburger
$6.49
Single hamburger with your choice of toppings.
 
Double Hamburger
$9.19
Double hamburger with your choice of toppings. 
 
Jumbo Cheeseburger
$7.19
Single hamburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings.
 
Double Cheeseburger
$10.19
Double cheeseburger with American cheese and your choice of toppings. 
 
Cedar-Burger
$9.39
Cheeseburger topped with Cedar Creek Winery's pinot grigio Swiss cheese spread, American cheese, bacon and fried onions. 
 
Mushroom Swiss Burger
$8.29
Cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
 
Double Mushroom Swiss Burger
$11.39
Double Cheeseburger with Swiss cheese and fried mushrooms.
 
Huge Hefner
$11.69
Double cheeseburger with extra bun slice, American cheese, lettuce, pickles, raw onion and Thousand Island Dressing.
 
Fish Sandwich
$6.69
Breaded cod fillet sandwich with your choice of toppings. 
 
Jaws
$10.49
Two breaded cod fillets sandwiched between a hamburger bun and topped with American cheese, lettuce, raw onion and tartar sauce.
 
Grilled Cheese
$3.99
 
Grilled Chicken
$7.29
Grilled chicken breast fillet with your choice of toppings.
 
Breaded Chicken
$7.29
Juicy chicken breast fillet breaded in flour and seasoned with salt, pepper, buttermilk and a hint of savory spices. 
 
Chicken Fingers
$7.29
Panko-crusted chicken tenderloins with your choice of dipping sauce.
 
Extras
 
  • Cheese $0.55
  • Bacon $1.50
  • Tomatoes $0.50
  • Butter $0.25
  • Gluten Free Bun $2.00

Sides

French Fries
$3.69
 
Onion Rings
$4.19
 
Cheese Curds
$5.49
 
Mozzarella Sticks
$6.19
Served with marinara. 
Breaded Mushrooms
$5.69
 
Fry / Ring Mix
$4.19
 
Fry / Tot Mix
$3.89
 
Fried Mini Tacos
$4.69
Served with sour cream and salsa.
 
Cheese Fries
$4.59
Served with cheese sauce on the side.
 
Tater Tots
$3.69

Lil Hef's Kids Meals

Choose one of each below for $6.59

MainSideDrink
Mini Corn Dogs French Fries Juice
Chicken Fingers Tater Tots Milk
Grilled Cheese Applesauce Soda

Upgrade the drink to a mini shake for $1.99

Drinks

Soda
$2.89 / $3.39

Coke, Diet Coke, Mountain Dew, Sprite, Lemonade, Sprecher Root Beer

Bottled Drinks
 

Gatorade $1.99

AriZona Arnold Palmer $2.49

Half iced tea, half lemonade

Water $0.99

Floats
$4.99
 
Chocolate Custard Soda
$4.79
 
Old-fashioned custard soda made with vanilla custard, carbonation and chocolate syrup.
 
Slushies    $2.29 / $2.59 / $2.89
 
Mango, fruit punch, cherry, grape, orange, blue raspberry, lemon-lime
 
Smoothies    $3.09 / $3.49 / $3.89
 
Blend of vanilla custard, sweet slushie and your flavor choice.
 
Mango, fruit punch, cherry, grape, orange, blue raspberry, lemon-lime
 
 
Strawberry    .75
Raspberry    .75
Chopped Cherries    .75
Blueberry    .75
Pineapple    .75
Bananas    .75
Whipped Cream    .75
 

Custard

Served Daily: Vanilla, Chocolate, Flavor of the Day and Dole® Whip Soft Serve

Cones & Dishes
 

Baby Scoop $3.09

1 Scoop $3.59

2 Scoop $4.59

3 Scoop $5.59

Waffle Cone $5.29

Served with two scoops of custard.

Pint $5.99

Quart $10.99

1/2 Gallon $17.49

Hefner's Specialty Sundaes
 

Turtle Sundae $5.99 / $7.49

One or three scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, caramel and pecans.

Banana Split $7.49

Three scoops of vanilla custard cradled by bananas and topped with chocolate syrup, raspberries, strawberries and crushed nuts.

Cashew Creation $7.49

Three scoops of vanilla custard topped with marshmallow, butterscotch and cashews.

Hefner's Delight $7.49

Three scoops of vanilla custard topped with hot fudge, marshmallow, butterscotch and pecans.

Caramel Brownie $6.99

Three scoops of vanilla custard topped with brownie pieces and caramel.

Doggie Delight (Dog Treat) $2.99

One scoop of vanilla custard topped with dog biscuits for your pooch!
 
 
 
Malts and Shakes $5.39 / $6.39
 

Flavors:

Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Raspberry, Hot Fudge, Butterscotch, Caramel, Peanut Butter, Cherry, Brownie, Marshmallow, Banana, Blueberry, Oreo, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, M&M's, Butterfinger, Pineapple, Mint 

 
 
 
 
Sundaes $5.29 / $6.29

Flavors:

Chocolate, Vanilla, Strawberry, Raspberry, Hot Fudge, Butterscotch, Caramel, Peanut Butter, Cherry, Brownie, Marshmallow, Banana, Blueberry, Oreo, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, M&M's, Butterfinger, Pineapple, Mint

 
Crushed Nuts $1, Peanuts $1
Almonds $1, Cashews $1.50, Pecans $1.50
 
WHITEOUT
$6.99
 
Heaping scoops of vanilla, chocolate or flavor of the day custard mixed with your choice of two toppings from our curated list.
 

Specials

March Sandwich of the Month: Lobster Roll
 
$9.49
Tom's homemade lobster salad recipe with real lobster, celery, onion and dill. Served in a wrap or on a French roll.
 
March Shake of the Month: Girl Scouts Thin Mints®
 
$6.19 / $7.19
Crushed Thin Mints® cookies blended in creamy vanilla custard.
 
Monday Special: Gyro
 
$8.99
Blend of lamb and beef gyro meat topped with tzatziki sauce, raw onions and tomatoes on a pita.
 
Tuesday Special: Burger Special
 
$3.99 / $4.49
Single hamburger or cheeseburger with your choice of toppings. Try out our Tuesday special today.
 
Wednesday Special: Sourdough Melt
 
$7.39
Cheeseburger topped with American cheese, Swiss cheese and fried onions on grilled sourdough bread.
 
Thursday Special: Philly Cheesesteak
 
$9.29
Thinly sliced steak topped with fried onions, sauteed peppers, provolone cheese and a classic American cheese spread. Served on a buttered and toasted roll.
 
Friday Special: Cod Fish Fry
 
$15.99
3-piece battered cod fish fry served with French fries, coleslaw, rye bread, tartar sauce and lemon.
 
Friday Special: Perch Fish Fry
 
$16.99
4-piece breaded perch fish fry served with French fries, coleslaw, tartar, rye bread and lemon.
N71W5184 Columbia Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012 262-376-0601
© 2026 Hefners Frozen Custard. All Rights Reserved.
  • Menu
  • History
  • Employment
  • Contact Us