Monthly Flavors
Flavor of the Day

Lemon Bar

Creamy vanilla custard loaded with chunks of Luscious Lemon Squares.

Sundae of the Month

Custard Cookie Sandwiches• 3” Oreo® cookie sandwiches filled with cookie dough custard, Oreo® custard or double chocolate chunk custard •Funnel Cake Fries• Fried funnel cake batter fries with vanilla custard and cinnamon sugar dusting •Strawberry Shortcake• Homemade Barthel Fruit Farm shortcake biscuit topped with vanilla custard, strawberries and whipped cream •Lemonade Slushies

Sandwich of the Month

Shrimp Po Boy• Southern-style breaded shrimp with lettuce, tomato and remoulade sauce on a French roll.

Bavarian Burger• Cheeseburger topped with American cheese, Swiss cheese, cheddar cheese sauce, bacon, fried onions and served on a pretzel bun.

Big Shot Fish Taco• Three fried cod pieces topped with sweet and sour coleslaw, pico de gallo and creamy poblano avocado sauce - on a cilantro jalapeño wrap.

Business Hours:
  • Monday11am - 9pm
  • Tuesday11am - 9pm
  • Wednesday11am - 9pm
  • Thursday11am - 9pm
  • Friday11am - 9pm
  • Saturday11am - 9pm
  • Sunday11am - 9pm
Questions: Contact us

Hefner’s Custard: Cedarburg’s Favorite American Classics.

Opened in 1995, Hefner's Custard has become a Cedarburg standard for freshly made local food. Located on the corner of Columbia and Keup, Hefner's serves delicious custard alongside a slew of American classics. Mouthwatering burgers, grilled chicken, fish fries and more are all freshly made to order to satisfy your cravings.

Pull into our custard stand's parking lot and enjoy one of our famous jumbo burgers with a scoop of Wisconsin's best custard for dessert. We boast a wonderful offering of outdoor seating for when Wisconsin's weather is at its finest and indoor counter seating year-round. We also host community events for your entertainment including corn roasts, school fundraisers, live music and more! Join the many customers from Cedarburg, Grafton, Thiensville, Germantown, Mequon, Richfield and the surrounding areas of Ozaukee County who have frequented Hefner's for years, we'll see you here!